How to Write a Fiction Book Review

How to Write a Fiction Book Review: Tips for Readers

You’ve finished a novel. You know whether you loved it, liked it, struggled with it, or couldn’t put it down.

Then you click Write a Review and suddenly…

What do you say?

Writing a fiction book review doesn’t have to be complicated. You don’t need to be a professional reviewer, analyze every aspect of the story, or write several paragraphs. A few thoughtful sentences about your experience with the book can make a great review.

This guide is specifically about reviewing fiction—the characters, plot, setting, writing and, most importantly, how the story made you feel.

If you’re not sure where to begin, start with three simple questions:

1. How did the book make you feel?
2. Did it engage you and keep you wanting to read?
3. Would you recommend it or read more by this author?

Those three questions are at the heart of a good fiction review.

Reviews don’t have to sound literary or serious. Sometimes a reader describes a book in a way I’d never think of—and that’s what makes the review memorable.

“… it was like grandma’s chocolate triple layered cake, hard to put down and impossible to walk away from…”

Sounds simple, doesn’t it?

It is—but knowing what you think about a story and figuring out how to put those thoughts into words aren’t always the same thing.

Three Things to Think About

1. How did the book make you feel?

Did it make you laugh? Cry? Get angry? Feel nervous? Did it surprise you? Frustrate you? Make you think?

Did you become emotionally invested in what happened to the characters?

And here’s an interesting question: Did you think about the book when you weren’t reading it?

Sometimes that’s one of the best indications that a story has pulled you in.

2. Did the book engage you?

Did you want to keep reading?

Were there places where you couldn’t put it down? Did you find yourself saying, “Just one more chapter”?

Did you want to know what happened next?

You don’t necessarily have to love every character or every decision they make to be engaged by a story. Sometimes a character you dislike can be every bit as compelling as one you love.

3. Would you recommend the book or read more by this author?

When you finished, did you want another book?

Would you recommend it to a friend who enjoys this type of story?

Would you read another book featuring these characters or written by this author?

Those three questions alone can give you everything you need for a short book review.

Think About the Characters

Characters are often what connect us most strongly to a story.

Start with the main character.

Did you like them? You don’t have to. Sometimes we’re not supposed to.

Instead, ask yourself:

• Did the character feel real?
• Could you picture them?
• Did you understand their choices, even when you disagreed with them?
• Did you care what happened to them?
• Did they remind you of anyone?
• Did you want them to succeed—or perhaps desperately want them to fail?
• Did they change as the story progressed?

Then think about the secondary characters.

Did they feel like real people rather than simply names on a page? Did they fit naturally into the story? Could you tell them apart? Did you understand who they were and why they were there?

Even minor characters should generally have a reason for appearing. You don’t have to analyze every character, but if someone particularly stood out—for good or bad—that can be worth mentioning in your review.

You might simply write:

“The characters felt so real that I found myself getting angry with some of their decisions.”

Or:

“I loved the relationship between the two main characters and how it developed throughout the story.”

That’s a review.

What one reader said:

“I loved Sam’s nosy, I-won’t-stand-for-any-crap character… which usually landed her in trouble, and in some cases a LOT of trouble.”

That’s a review. The reader tells us how she felt about Sam, gives us a sense of Sam’s personality, and even hints at the trouble ahead—without telling us what happens.

Think About the Plot

You don’t need to summarize the plot. In fact, readers looking at reviews usually already have the book description available to them.

Instead, tell them how you experienced the story.

Did the plot keep moving?

Did it hold your interest?

Did you want to know what happened next?

Did it keep you guessing?

Were you surprised by the twists?

Did the different storylines eventually fit together?

A mystery, suspense or thriller may deliberately leave you confused about certain things along the way. That’s part of the fun. The more important question is whether the pieces eventually came together and made sense.

Did you reach the end and think:

“Oh! Now I understand why that happened.”

Or did something that seemed insignificant earlier suddenly become important?

Those are great things to talk about—as long as you don’t give away the surprise.

What one reader said:

“I LOVED this book! It was fast-paced and had me gripped from the start… And talk about twists! Just when I thought I knew where this story was leading… Bang!… Plot twist!”

The enthusiasm tells another reader almost everything they need to know: fast-paced, gripping and unpredictable. No plot summary required.

Watch Out for Spoilers

Try not to reveal major twists, surprises, deaths, the identity of the villain, or how the book ends.

Instead of:

“I couldn’t believe _____ was actually the killer!”

Try:

“I didn’t see the final reveal coming, but when I looked back, the clues were there.”

You’re telling prospective readers what you liked without taking away their opportunity to experience it themselves.

Think About the Setting

Setting won’t necessarily matter to every review, but sometimes the location becomes an important part of the reading experience.

Could you picture where the story took place?

Did the descriptions make you feel as though you were there?

Was it somewhere you’ve visited? Somewhere familiar? Or somewhere you’d now like to see?

Perhaps the setting created a particular mood—isolated, cozy, creepy, dangerous, beautiful or claustrophobic.

If the setting stood out to you, mention it.

“The small-town setting felt so real I could picture myself walking down the main street.”

That’s useful information for another reader.

Think About the Writing

You can also talk about how the story was told.

Every author approaches storytelling differently, and every reader has preferences.

Did you like the author’s writing style?

Was the story fast-paced or more leisurely?

Were the chapters short or long?

Was it told from one character’s point of view or several?

Did you enjoy multiple points of view—or did you prefer one character’s perspective?

Was the story told in past or present tense, and did that affect your experience?

Did the dialogue sound natural?

Did the descriptions help you picture what was happening?

If you’ve read other books by the author, you can mention that too. How did this one compare? Did it give you what you’ve come to enjoy about that author’s books?

You can even mention another author if the writing or story genuinely reminded you of their work.

For example:

“Readers who enjoy twisty, character-driven thrillers may enjoy this one.”

You don’t need to understand technical writing terms. You’re simply describing what worked—or didn’t work—for you as a reader.

Keep the Review About the Book

A book review should primarily be about your experience with the book.

It’s absolutely okay to say that something didn’t work for you. An honest review isn’t required to be positive.

Maybe the pacing was too slow for your taste. Maybe you struggled to connect with a character. Maybe multiple points of view aren’t your favourite style. Maybe you loved the first half but found the ending less satisfying.

Those are all legitimate reactions to the book.

Try to explain why.

Instead of:

“I hated this.”

Something like:

“I had trouble connecting with the main character, so I wasn’t as emotionally invested in the story as I’d hoped.”

That tells another reader something useful.

Focus on the story, characters, writing, pacing and your reading experience rather than making the review personal about the author.

Your Review Doesn’t Have to Be Long

This may be the most important thing to remember.

A useful book review can be two or three sentences.

You don’t have to discuss the characters, plot, setting, writing style and everything else on this page.

Choose the things that mattered most to you.

For example:

“This book pulled me in from the beginning. I loved the characters, and every time I thought I had figured out what was happening, something changed. The twists kept me guessing right to the end. I’d definitely read more in this series.”

That’s a perfectly useful review.

You could write more.

You could write less.

The goal isn’t to write the “perfect” review.

It’s simply to tell another reader:

How did this book make me feel?

Did it keep me engaged?

Would I recommend it or want to read more?

Start there.

The rest is just putting your experience into your own words.

Stuck? Finish One of These Sentences

Sometimes the hardest part of writing a review is simply figuring out how to start.

Don’t overthink it. Pick one of these sentences and finish it in your own words. You might be surprised how quickly the rest of your review follows.

1. I couldn’t stop reading because…
2. The character I liked the most was… because…
3. The character who frustrated, surprised or intrigued me the most was…
4. The plot kept me…
5. Just when I thought I knew what was going to happen…
6. The thing I enjoyed most about this book was…
7. This story made me feel…
8. This book reminded me of… because…
9. When I wasn’t reading, I found myself thinking about…
10. I would recommend this book to readers who…

You don’t have to use all ten. You don’t even have to use two.

Choose one that makes you immediately think of an answer. Finish the sentence, explain why you felt that way, and you may already have the beginning of your review.

If you enjoyed this article you might enjoy these:

Why We Read – Click here

What Makes a Villain Memorable – Click here.